Series: “The Russian Books Everyone Argued About in 2020.” Part 3 of 4.
By Irakli Gagua
Please note: this novel contains a great deal of strong language and harsh scenes. It is strictly a book for adults; this article is written for parents.
Ask which book of 2020 caused the most argument among writers and critics themselves, and the answer will probably be Earth («Земля») by Mikhail Elizarov. The novel came out from Elena Shubina’s imprint in the autumn of 2019 (the imprint page says 2020) and stayed at the center of attention throughout the following year. In the summer of 2020 it won the National Bestseller prize; in December it won the Big Book readers’ vote — and yet received no prize from the Big Book jury. Konstantin Milchin wrote plainly in Gorky that the main prize should have gone to Elizarov.
What the Novel Is About
The hero is Vladimir Krotyshev, nicknamed “the Mole,” born in 1986. Since childhood he has been inexplicably drawn to cemeteries and to the subject of death. We follow him growing up in the late-Soviet and post-Soviet provinces, through army service, and then into work as a gravedigger and guard in his half-brother’s funeral business. Its nearly 800 pages are both a “workplace” novel about the funeral trade, with its everyday life and jargon, and a philosophical novel in which characters hold long debates about the nature of death.
A “Russian Thanatos”
The publishers presented the book as the first large-scale exploration of a “Russian thanatos” — the Russian attitude to death. The title has a double meaning: earth is both the grave and the soil from which everything grows. The ending is open, and the subtitle The Digger led many critics to see the book as the first part of a larger cycle, although the author himself has not promised a sequel.
What the Critics Said
Opinions were sharply divided. Supporters call Earth Elizarov’s best book: Alexei Kolobrodov praised its mature style, free of unnecessary ornament (it is worth noting that he also nominated the novel for the National Bestseller). Mikhail Vizel (God Literatury) heard echoes of Pelevin and read the ending as cautiously hopeful. Opponents faulted the novel for verbosity and incompleteness: Lidia Maslova (Izvestia) wrote that the author loses control of the composition, and Vladislav Tolstov that its small, vulgar characters cannot carry the epic ambition.
A View from Faith
For an Orthodox reader, the theme of this novel is not foreign at all. For centuries the Church has taught the “remembrance of death” and reminded us, in the words of Genesis, “dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.” But in Elizarov’s book the conversation about death takes place without hope of the Resurrection — it is a philosophy of earth without heaven. That is exactly why the book matters as a testimony: it shows how painfully a person thinks about death when the language of faith has been taken from him, and how he tries to replace it with home-made metaphysics.
My Verdict
Earth is a heavy, coarse and very serious book. No one would call it pleasant reading, but it is hard to deny that it is one of the most significant statements in Russian prose of recent years. The Big Book readers sensed this better than the jury. The novel is not suitable for children or teenagers, and adults should approach it knowing what awaits them.
The Series
- Newton’s Blueprint by Alexander Ilichevsky
- The Invincible Sun by Victor Pelevin
- Earth by Mikhail Elizarov (you are reading it)
- The Garden by Marina Stepnova (October 19)
Read this article in Russian: «Земля» Михаила Елизарова.
Sources: Gorky, God Literatury, Izvestia, REN TV, Prochtenie, the official Big Book Prize website, Wikipedia.